
BRAZIL · SUPREME COURT
Key Facts
- What happened Brazil’s highest court votes on Tuesday on whether police may investigate Justice Alexandre de Moraes.
- Why it is unusual O Globo, a leading Brazilian newspaper, found no earlier vote on investigating a sitting justice.
- What started it A police report describes messages sent to the justice by Daniel Vorcaro, founder of the failed Banco Master.
- Why it matters to you Brazil’s top court tries its senior politicians, so its authority shapes how the country is governed.
- The catch The vote only opens an inquiry. Moraes has not been charged, and nobody here has been convicted.
- What comes next A second session on 23 September examines Justice Andre Mendonca, who handled the linked bank files.
The Brazil Supreme Court votes on Tuesday on whether police may investigate Justice Alexandre de Moraes. O Globo found no precedent for such a session.
A police file reached every justice in Brasilia on 10 September. Five days later the Brazil Supreme Court votes on whether the colleague named inside it can be investigated.
The file that went round the court
The court registers it as Petition 16,662. Inside sit a Federal Police report and the material gathered with it.
The report describes messages that banker Daniel Vorcaro sent to Justice Alexandre de Moraes. Vorcaro founded Banco Master, a mid-sized bank that collapsed in 2025.
O Globo reported that the court’s president, Edson Fachin, sent the whole file to his colleagues on 10 September. The vote falls five days later.
The full court meets in extraordinary session on Tuesday, 15 September 2026, in Brasilia. The session is listed as a public one.
The justices decide one question only: whether police may open an inquiry. It is not a trial, and Moraes has not been charged with any crime.
Twelve days from a police report to a plenary vote
On 3 September Fachin opened a procedure into the police reports. He gave four officials five working days to answer him in writing.
The four were Moraes, Justice Andre Mendonca, Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet and Federal Police chief Andrei Rodrigues. Poder360 reported that their deadline expired on Friday, 11 September.
What the four sent back has stayed inside the court. Fachin moved ahead in the days that followed.
On 9 September he suspended every procedure against justices and fixed the plenary date. He also took Moraes off the fake news inquiry Moraes had led.
Fachin then gave the Federal Police 24 hours to explain how the original Vorcaro phone material had been stored. The police answered that the data was intact.
Who sits in the room on Tuesday
The Supreme Federal Court, known at home as the STF, is Brazil’s highest court. It hears the cases against senior politicians and officials who carry special legal standing.
Edson Fachin has presided over it since September 2025. The president sets the agenda and can open procedures inside the court.
Paulo Gonet runs the Prosecutor-General’s Office, called the PGR in Brazil. His office decides whether to ask the court for criminal charges.
Andrei Rodrigues directs the Federal Police, the PF, Brazil’s national investigative force. It gathers evidence and reports to the courts.
Moraes and Mendonca both sit on the bench. Neither has been charged with a crime.
Nobody can point to a precedent
O Globo reported on 10 September that the court will rule for the first time on investigating a sitting justice. The paper found no clear model for the session.
The court was created in 1891 and turned 135 in February 2026. In all those years no comparable case has been cited.
Some scholars reach back to the fake news inquiry the court opened in 2019. That inquiry let the president start an investigation and hand it to a colleague.
Others read the court’s criminal reach over its own members as narrow. In their view it covers justices accused of crimes, not wider scrutiny.
Fachin’s written questions asked whether the police had followed the Loman. That 1979 law sets out how Brazil’s judiciary is organised and how judges may be disciplined.
Where the Banco Master files sit now
Fachin made himself sole rapporteur of the Moraes and Vorcaro case on Saturday, 12 September. He acted alone, using a power written into the court’s internal rules.
The same decision took Mendonca off the linked Banco Master and social security files. Those cover alleged fraud at the bank and at the INSS, the national social security institute.
Mendonca handed the papers over without protest. He had already suspended his own action and sent it upward.
On 11 September he lifted secrecy on 39 court proceedings. The prosecutor-general had asked for 18.
Thirteen retired justices had written to Fachin three days earlier. They urged him to call an urgent public session and answer the storm around the court.
What Tuesday can and cannot settle
The session covers the Moraes matter alone. A separate session on 23 September examines Mendonca’s own conduct as rapporteur.
A yes vote opens a police inquiry and does nothing more. Nobody in this case has been convicted of anything.
Prosecutors would still have to decide later whether to seek charges. That step is not on this week’s agenda.
Brasilia will learn on Tuesday whether the court is willing to look inward. The answer shapes every step that follows.
More: Brazil news in English, every day from The Rio Times.
The big picture: Brazil explained — economy, politics, society and daily life in one read.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Alexandre de Moraes?
A justice of Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court. He led the court’s fake news inquiry until Edson Fachin removed him from it on 9 September.
Can a Brazilian Supreme Court justice be investigated?
The court itself decides. On Tuesday the justices vote on whether police may open an inquiry into one of their own members.
What was Banco Master?
A mid-sized Brazilian bank that grew quickly and collapsed in 2025. Its founder, Daniel Vorcaro, sent the messages described in the police report.
When does the court decide?
The full court meets in extraordinary session in Brasilia on Tuesday, 15 September 2026. The session is a public one.
Sources: Sources: O Globo, Folha de S.Paulo, G1, Poder360, Agencia Brasil. https://oglobo.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/09/10/stf-decidira-pela-primeira-vez-se-ministro-sera-investigado-entenda-o-rito-e-o-que-sera-decidido-na-sessao-inedita.ghtml https://oglobo.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/09/03/fachin-da-5-dias-para-moraes-e-mendonca-se-manifestarem-sobre-relatorio-da-pf-com-mensagens-de-vorcaro.ghtml https://oglobo.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/09/09/fachin-suspende-todo-procedimento-contra-ministros-do-stf-e-marca-para-dia-15-julgamento-de-relatorio-sobre-moraes.ghtml https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/poder/2026/09/fachin-tira-de-mendonca-relatoria-de-caso-moraes-e-abre-caminho-para-assumir-inqueritos-do-master-e-inss.shtml
This article was produced by The Rio Times’ automated AI newsroom. Editorial responsibility: Matthias Camenzind, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief. The Rio Times also runs Ask Rio Times, which answers from 100,000+ of our own articles, the daily Latin America Power Map, and prediction-market odds on elections and markets.. How we use AI · Report an error
Brazil runoff, Sunday, October 25: When is the Brazil runoff election. Latest: Brazil runoff polls, Flávio 51%, Lula 49%.