Brazil’s Police Leaders Back Their Ousted Chief Weeks Before the Election
Key Facts
Brazil’s Supreme Court and its Federal Police are now in open conflict, less than a month before a presidential election. Eleven of the force’s fifteen directors have offered to quit after a single justice removed their chief.

On 8 September, Supreme Court justice André Mendonça removed Andrei Passos Rodrigues, head of Brazil’s Federal Police, by court order. The same day, eleven of the force’s fifteen directors put their posts at the disposal of the interim chief.
Why This Matters
The Federal Police is Brazil’s national investigative force, roughly comparable to the FBI in the United States. It answers to the Ministry of Justice and Public Security and had 17,658 employees in 2023.
It runs major corruption and fraud inquiries, including the Banco Master bank case that now reaches the courts. The Supreme Federal Court, known as the STF, is Brazil’s top court and has eleven justices.
Justices are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, and they also try cases against senior politicians. A clash between the two bodies therefore touches investigations that could shape the election campaign.
Brazilians vote in the first round of the presidential election on 4 October 2026. The removed police chief was chosen by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s government in 2023.
André Mendonça was appointed to the court by Lula’s predecessor, Jair Bolsonaro, and took his seat in December 2021. Those origins mean each side’s supporters read the clash through a partisan lens.
What the Directors Actually Did
On 8 September, eleven of the fifteen directors placed their posts at the disposal of the interim director-general. In Brazilian public service that phrase is a formal gesture, meaning the officials will go if wanted.
It also signals collective protest, and none of the eleven has actually left. Their statement declared total support for Andrei Passos Rodrigues and praised his work as technical, impartial and responsible.
They called the attacks on him unjustified. They also rejected what they described as narratives driven by electoral interests.
Who the Removed Chief Is
Andrei Rodrigues became director-general in January 2023, at the start of Lula’s current term. He was recommended to Lula by Flávio Dino, who was justice minister at the time.
Rodrigues previously led security for Lula’s 2022 presidential campaign and his transition team. His directors, who know that history, still describe his work as technical and impartial.
Why the Chief Was Removed
Mendonça ordered the preventive removal of two officials on 8 September, the director-general and Leandro Almada. Almada is the director of police intelligence, though English coverage often mentions only Rodrigues.
Mendonça says at least six police intelligence reports produced in August tracked him and the solicitor general. He issued the order himself, in a matter where he says he is the person who was monitored.
The trigger was a petition from Novo, a small pro-market opposition party. Mendonça acted without first hearing the prosecutor general, Brazil’s top federal prosecutor.
The Government’s Appeal and the 72-Hour Deadline
The government appealed the same day through Solicitor General Jorge Messias, its chief lawyer. Messias argued that the removal cuts across the president’s authority over the Federal Police.
He also warned of institutional disorganisation inside the force. Edson Fachin, the Supreme Court’s president, gave Mendonça 72 hours to respond, which some outlets describe as three days.
Messias and Justice Minister Wellington César Lima e Silva went to see Fachin in person. Lula then called an unscheduled meeting with both men.
Lula himself has said nothing publicly about the crisis. He spent the day signing decrees creating four Amazon reserves.
The Panel Vote That Stopped Halfway
The court’s Second Panel, one of two smaller chambers of justices, began voting in a virtual session. Mendonça himself, Luiz Fux and Kássio Nunes Marques backed the order, forming a majority.
Then Gilmar Mendes asked for more time to study the file, which under Brazilian practice halts the ruling. The removal remains in force while the case is paused, so the police chief is out without a final decision.
Fux, who chairs the panel, had already cancelled its scheduled afternoon session before voting in the virtual one. Gilmar Mendes argued the case belongs before the full court and warned of an imbalance in the election campaign.
Who Is Who, and Where English Coverage Slips
André Mendonça is a Supreme Court justice, not Brazil’s justice minister, as several English reports say. The justice minister is Wellington César Lima e Silva.
Alexandre de Moraes, who appears throughout this story, is also a Supreme Court justice. Andrei Rodrigues was not fired, because a court order removed him as a precautionary measure that a higher ruling can undo.
William Marcel Murad was not appointed to replace him either. As executive director, he is second in the line of succession and took over automatically.
The distinction shapes what happens next, since a reinstatement would not require a new appointment. Brazil’s finance minister is Dário Durigan, who took the post in March, not Fernando Haddad.
The Other Side, and the Wider Protest
Mendonça’s order rests on his claim that police intelligence tracked a sitting justice and the solicitor general. Three colleagues on the panel agreed that the removal should stand, at least for now.
The national association of Federal Police chief inspectors said the removal trampled proper procedure. It argued that removing a director-general should come from the full court, not from one justice acting alone.
The Federal Police staff union condemned what it called the political use of the judiciary against the force. Separately, thirteen retired Supreme Court justices wrote to Fachin about the court’s most acute crisis in its history.
The signatories include Celso de Mello, Ellen Gracie, Joaquim Barbosa and Rosa Weber. They asked for an urgent public session of the full bench, the same demand the chief inspectors made.
Why This Is Happening Now
The dispute is tangled with the Banco Master affair, the failure of a private bank the Central Bank liquidated in November 2025. Mendonça had lifted secrecy on police material referring to Alexandre de Moraes in that case.
Moraes has asked Fachin to investigate Mendonça in return. Fernando Haddad, a former finance minister now running for the governing party in São Paulo, called for the files to be opened.
He argued that a close election makes disclosure decisive. The timing, less than a month before the vote, is not incidental to anyone involved.
What It Means If You Follow Brazil
For investors, the episode adds to institutional uncertainty rather than to any direct economic risk. Politically sensitive investigations could slow while the police leadership is in dispute.
Readers should expect both campaigns to use the clash to argue that the other side controls the institutions. Any ruling from the full court would set a precedent for how far one justice can reach into the executive.
What Is Not Yet Known
It is not known how Mendonça will answer Fachin, or whether Fachin will call the full court. It is not known when Gilmar Mendes will return the file and let the panel vote end.
The intelligence reports that Mendonça cites have not been published. Whether Rodrigues returns, or whether the directors follow through on their offer, remains open.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does this matter?
The Federal Police runs Brazil’s most sensitive investigations, and its leadership is now in conflict with the Supreme Court. The clash comes weeks before the 4 October election.
Did eleven Federal Police directors resign?
No, they offered to give up their posts. That is a formal protest gesture in Brazilian public service, and all eleven remain in place.
Who removed the Federal Police chief, and can it be undone?
Supreme Court justice André Mendonça ordered it as a precautionary measure on 8 September. The court’s Second Panel began voting to uphold it, then paused.
Who is running the Federal Police now?
Executive director William Marcel Murad. He took over automatically as second in the line of succession, rather than being appointed.
Sources: Agência Brasil, the Second Panel vote and the pause, Agência Brasil, the staff union statement, InfoMoney, the eleven directors, Poder360, Fachin’s three-day deadline, Gazeta do Povo, the chief inspectors’ association, Gazeta do Povo, Fux cancels the panel session, CartaCapital, the retired justices’ letter, Poder360, Gilmar Mendes on the full bench, Wikipedia, the Federal Police of Brazil, Wikipedia, Andrei Rodrigues, Wikipedia, the Supreme Federal Court and its justices, B3 Bora Investir, the Central Bank’s Banco Master liquidation
In depth
This article was produced by The Rio Times’ automated AI newsroom. Editorial responsibility: Matthias Camenzind, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief. The Rio Times also runs Ask Rio Times, which answers from 100,000+ of our own articles, the daily Latin America Power Map, and prediction-market odds on elections and markets.. How we use AI · Report an error
Brazil runoff, Sunday, October 25: Brazil runoff: date, poll closing times and when results start. Latest: Brazil runoff polls, Flávio 51%, Lula 49%.