Brazil STF: Thirteen Retired Justices Write to Fachin
BRAZIL · INSTITUTIONS
Key Facts
- —What happened Thirteen retired Supreme Federal Court justices signed a letter to Chief Justice Edson Fachin.
- —What they want A public, immediate and rigorous investigation into what they call extremely grave facts damaging the Court.
- —Who signed Signatories include three former chief justices: Joaquim Barbosa, Rosa Weber and Carlos Ayres Britto.
- —The wording They describe it as the most severe crisis in the Court’s recent trajectory.
- —The catch The letter refers to extremely grave facts. It does not name Moraes or Vorcaro.
- —What Fachin did He cancelled a scheduled meeting with the national bar association about the crisis.
Runoff · Sunday, 25 October
Brazil Runoff 2026: Lula vs Flávio
Date, polls, debates, odds and how the runoff works, updated every day.
Read our Brazil election 2026 runoff guide →
Brazil runoff polls · Polymarket and Kalshi odds · When results come · Brazil election poll data (CSV)
Prediction markets · who wins the runoff
Implied chance of winning Brazil’s presidency on 25 October, from traders’ prices.
Polymarket
Flávio Bolsonaro 76.7% · Lula 23.5% (US$193 million traded)
Kalshi (regulated in the US by the CFTC)
Flávio Bolsonaro 76% · Lula 25%
As of 23 October, 5:40 pm ET (22:40 Lisbon), updated every 20 minutes. Prices are bets, not polls, and can move fast.
Why we show this: prediction markets turn real-money bets into a live probability that moves within minutes of the news, which is why investors, campaigns and newsrooms in the United States now follow them closely. We show them next to polls and official results, never instead of them.
Former members of a court do not usually write to it. Thirteen Brazil STF veterans did, and they asked for the session to be held in public.
Thirteen retired justices of Brazil STF have written to the Court’s current chief justice. They want an investigation, and they want it held in the open.
The letter was addressed to Chief Justice Luiz Edson Fachin and was made public on Monday 7 September.
They asked him to convene a public session with all urgency, so that the full bench could order an immediate and rigorous investigation under due process.
The letter refers to extremely grave facts compromising the Court’s standing. It does not name any justice, and the link to the Moraes case is the press’s framing rather than the letter’s wording.
Why a Brazil STF Letter Like This Is Unusual
Former members of a supreme court rarely intervene in its internal affairs. Convention treats the sitting court as the only body competent to police itself.
Three former chief justices signed. Joaquim Barbosa, Rosa Weber and Carlos Ayres Britto each led the Court in different periods.
The full list also includes Neri da Silveira, Francisco Rezek, Sydney Sanches, Celso de Mello, Carlos Velloso, Ilmar Galvao, Nelson Jobim, Ellen Gracie, Cezar Peluso and Eros Grau.
The demand for a public session is the sharper part. An internal inquiry held privately is what the letter appears designed to prevent.
What the Crisis Is About
The press links the letter to unsealed federal police material containing messages between Justice Alexandre de Moraes and Daniel Vorcaro, the former owner of Banco Master, who was arrested in November 2025.
The Rio Times has not seen the messages and does not characterise their contents. What is established is that their existence has produced this reaction.
Street protests demanding Moraes’s removal have run in state capitals across Brazil. One outlet counted fifteen cities.
The letter moves the dispute from the street into the institution. That is a different order of pressure.
Fachin Under Pressure From Two Sides
Fachin called off a meeting set for Wednesday 9 September with the Order of Attorneys of Brazil and its president Beto Simonetti. No explanation and no new date were given.
Simonetti said on 7 September that the Court must give fast and clear answers, not to weaken it but to preserve it. He called an extraordinary meeting of the bar’s college of presidents for the same Wednesday.
A chief justice facing his own predecessors on one side and the bar on the other has limited room. Neither constituency can be ignored.
What to Watch
The first marker is whether a plenary session is convened, and whether it is public. That is the specific demand.
The second is whether the bar meeting is rescheduled. Its cancellation removed the one forum where the Court faced outside questions this week.
The third is the political calendar. Brazil votes in 2026, and a Supreme Court crisis in an election year rarely stays inside the courthouse.
More: Brazil news in English, every day from The Rio Times.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who wrote the letter?
Thirteen retired justices, including former chief justices Joaquim Barbosa, Rosa Weber, Carlos Ayres Britto, Nelson Jobim, Cezar Peluso, Ellen Gracie, Sydney Sanches and Neri da Silveira, alongside Celso de Mello, Francisco Rezek, Carlos Velloso, Ilmar Galvao and Eros Grau.
What are they asking for?
A public session convened with all urgency, so the full bench can order an immediate and rigorous investigation under due process into what the letter calls extremely grave facts. The letter does not name any justice.
How has the Court responded?
Chief Justice Edson Fachin called off a meeting set for 9 September with the bar association and its president Beto Simonetti, without explanation or a new date. Simonetti had said the Court must give fast and clear answers to preserve rather than weaken it.
Sources: Metropoles, A Gazeta, Poder360, Jovem Pan, BBC News Brasil, Rio Times.
This article was drafted with automated assistance and reviewed before publication. How we use AI · Report an error · Editorial responsibility: Matthias Camenzind, Editor-in-Chief