IBOV 166,376.43 ▼ 0.69% COLCAP 2,452.46 — — IPC MEX 68,713.60 ▼ 0.64% MERVAL 2,848,945 — — USD/BRL5.95▲ 0.24% USD/MXN19.07▼ 0.09% USD/CLP1,022▲ 0.54% USD/COP3,502▲ 4.34% USD/PEN3.46▲ 0.21% USD/ARS1,580▲ 0.93% USD/UYU40.61▲ 3.16% USD/PYG6,212▲ 2.34% USD/BOB11.64▲ 2.55% USD/DOP59.77▼ 0.38% USD/CRC441.73▲ 2.68% USD/GTQ7.64▲ 3.22% USD/HNL26.89▲ 3.31% USD/NIO36.62▲ 0.34% USD/VES913.46▼ 0.45% USD/PAB1.00— 0.00% USD/BZD2.00— 0.00% USD/JMD157.59▲ 2.60% USD/TTD6.70▲ 2.00% EUR/BRL6.52▲ 1.15% BRENT 89.59 ▼ 2.60% WTI 83.18 ▼ 0.04% IRON ORE 161.91 — — COPPER 5.51 ▼ 2.04% GOLD 3,541 ▼ 3.93% SILVER 41.53 ▼ 6.30% SOY 1,223 ▲ 1.30% CORN 449.50 ▲ 2.39% WHEAT 591.75 ▲ 2.33% COFFEE 268.70 ▼ 4.73% SUGAR 17.07 ▼ 0.52% ORANGE JUICE 129.15 ▼ 2.57% COTTON 79.30 ▲ 4.41% COCOA 5,294 ▲ 4.56% BEEF 227.73 ▲ 2.19% CATTLE 335.30 ▼ 0.81% LITHIUM 52.71 ▼ 2.98% PETR4 42.67 ▼ 1.16% VALE3 58.48 ▼ 0.88% ITUB4 40.07 ▼ 0.30% BBDC4 13.83 ▼ 1.78% ABEV3 16.08 ▲ 0.06% BBAS3 14.30 ▲ 1.27% B3SA3 14.28 ▼ 0.14% WEGE3 51.13 ▼ 0.49% PRIO3 60.20 ▼ 2.70% SUZB3 55.32 ▼ 0.50% RENT3 28.86 ▼ 2.00% AZZA3 14.63 ▼ 7.29% CSAN3 3.08 ▼ 1.60% RAIZ4 15.00 ▼ 10.71% PCAR3 3.23 ▲ 8.03% GMAT3 4.18 ▲ 3.21% PSSA3 43.96 ▼ 1.57% CVCB3 0.72 ▼ 7.69% POSI3 3.37 ▲ 6.31% SLCE3 17.53 ▼ 1.96% NATU3 4.48 ▼ 6.28% BRKM5 2.60 ▼ 1.14% RANI3 8.01 ▼ 0.74% IBOV 166,376.43 ▼ 0.69% COLCAP 2,452.46 — — IPC MEX 68,713.60 ▼ 0.64% MERVAL 2,848,945 — — USD/BRL 5.95 ▲ 0.24% USD/MXN 19.07 ▼ 0.07% USD/CLP 1,023 ▲ 0.57% USD/COP 3,502 ▲ 4.34% USD/PEN 3.46 ▲ 0.21% USD/ARS 1,580 ▲ 0.93% USD/UYU 40.61 ▲ 3.16% USD/PYG 6,212 ▲ 2.34% USD/BOB 11.64 ▲ 2.55% USD/DOP 59.77 ▼ 0.38% USD/CRC 441.73 ▲ 2.68% USD/GTQ 7.64 ▲ 3.22% USD/HNL 26.89 ▲ 3.31% USD/NIO 36.62 ▲ 0.34% USD/VES 913.46 ▼ 0.45% USD/PAB 1.00 — 0.00% USD/BZD 2.00 — 0.00% USD/JMD 157.59 ▲ 2.60% USD/TTD 6.70 ▲ 2.00% EUR/BRL 6.52 ▲ 1.15% BRENT 89.59 ▼ 2.60% WTI 83.18 ▼ 0.04% IRON ORE 161.91 — — COPPER 5.51 ▼ 2.04% GOLD 3,541 ▼ 3.93% SILVER 41.53 ▼ 6.30% SOY 1,223 ▲ 1.30% CORN 449.50 ▲ 2.39% WHEAT 591.75 ▲ 2.33% COFFEE 268.70 ▼ 4.73% SUGAR 17.07 ▼ 0.52% ORANGE JUICE 129.15 ▼ 2.57% COTTON 79.30 ▲ 4.41% COCOA 5,294 ▲ 4.56% BEEF 227.73 ▲ 2.19% CATTLE 335.30 ▼ 0.81% LITHIUM 52.71 ▼ 2.98% PETR4 42.67 ▼ 1.16% VALE3 58.48 ▼ 0.88% ITUB4 40.07 ▼ 0.30% BBDC4 13.83 ▼ 1.78% ABEV3 16.08 ▲ 0.06% BBAS3 14.30 ▲ 1.27% B3SA3 14.28 ▼ 0.14% WEGE3 51.13 ▼ 0.49% PRIO3 60.20 ▼ 2.70% SUZB3 55.32 ▼ 0.50% RENT3 28.86 ▼ 2.00% AZZA3 14.63 ▼ 7.29% CSAN3 3.08 ▼ 1.60% RAIZ4 15.00 ▼ 10.71% PCAR3 3.23 ▲ 8.03% GMAT3 4.18 ▲ 3.21% PSSA3 43.96 ▼ 1.57% CVCB3 0.72 ▼ 7.69% POSI3 3.37 ▲ 6.31% SLCE3 17.53 ▼ 1.96% NATU3 4.48 ▼ 6.28% BRKM5 2.60 ▼ 1.14% RANI3 8.01 ▼ 0.74%
since 2009
Friday, November 20, 2026

Opinion: Brazil’s top court is deepening the divide

By · · 2 min read
Opinion: Brazil’s top court is deepening the divide

(Opinion) Brazil’s top court STF made today a controversial decision and deepened the divide between left and right.

This latest ruling has everyone talking. Aécio Lúcio Costa Pereira, one of many Bolsonaro supporters, faced their judgment.

RT
Ask Rio Times
17 years of Latin America reporting, on demand.
Open the full Ask Rio Times →

His crime? Storming and breaking into the Senate on January 8th and not being a supporter of Lula. The response of the judges was swift and firm.

A jaw-dropping 17 years behind bars. On top of that, a hefty 44 thousand reais (US$9,000) fine. That’s not all.

An additional 30 million reais (US$6 million) is demanded for collective moral damages. It’s a daunting figure. And Pereira isn’t alone.

The LatAm Brief

One email, every weekday morning. What moved in Latin American markets, politics and expat life.

Yesterday’s subject line: “Mexico's election chief won't be named before late January”

(Brazil’s top court deepened today the divide between left and right – Storming of the Congress building on January 8)

There are 231 other individuals accused, waiting in the wings.

In this one case, it’s more than just Pereira. It suggests a potentially alarming precedent for Brazil. The focus seems to be shifting.

From judging individual actions to a broad-brush approach. A majority of the court’s Justices back this view.

All, that is, except for Kassio Nunes Marques. His lone voice offers a different perspective.

It’s concerning. The majority’s view hints at collective culpability. But is that the right approach?

Collective judgments are a murky area. Every guilt should be personal, and individual. However, the court leans toward the “multitudinous crime” theory.

It’s a tactic that waters down personal responsibility, making mass convictions more feasible.

Of course, evidence is pivotal. Videos, witness accounts, and even confessions matter. Justice Alexandre de Moraes showcased several against Pereira during the session.

The influence of such presentations on judgments is unmistakable. But, parts of the evidence pool seem ambiguous.

Are we looking at genuine coup attempts? Or just high-spirited, perhaps misguided protests?

Where are the weapons, the violence, and the military?

The division among the Justices is evident. Some view it as a mere disturbance. Others, a threat to democracy.

The election shadows many views. The 2022 election, its controversies, and its aftermath seem to underpin many arguments.

Open Wounds

This decision doesn’t heal old wounds between the left and right. Instead, it agitates the already turbulent waters, deepening the divide in the country.

Defense perspectives raise pressing questions. Were the charges against Pereira too broad? Were they crafted to fit a narrative?

Pereira’s attorney certainly believes so. He challenges the claim of a genuine coup attempt. The evidence, he suggests, might be overblown. These aren’t trivial concerns.

Wrapping up, this Pereira case serves as a wake-up call. Our justice system must be thorough and nuanced, not generalized.

The implications are vast. It’s about Pereira today. But tomorrow? The direction we’re headed could redefine justice in Brazil.

Our democracy’s strength and resilience hang in the balance.

This article was produced by The Rio Times’ automated AI newsroom. Editorial responsibility: Matthias Camenzind, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief. The Rio Times also runs Ask Rio Times, which answers from 100,000+ of our own articles, the daily Latin America Power Map, and prediction-market odds on elections and markets.. How we use AI · Report an error

Read More from The Rio Times

The Rio Times · Power Map
See who really holds power in Latin America
Click to open the Power Map →

Brazil runoff date: Sunday, October 25, poll closing times and when results start · Brazil runoff polls: Flávio 51%, Lula 49% · Kalshi and Polymarket odds

Rotate for Best Experience

This report is optimized for landscape viewing. Rotate your phone for the full experience.