Cosan’s Potential Sale of Vale Shares Sparks Speculation Behind Rising Short Selling Activity

The recent surge in short selling of Vale S.A. (VALE3) shares has caught the attention of market analysts and investors alike.

Over a 24-hour period, the number of Vale shares available for borrowing increased by an astonishing 40%, rising from 111,000 to 154,000.

This spike occurred without any clear justification, especially given that Vale’s stock has already fallen by 20% this year, marking its worst performance since 2015.

Despite this decline, analysts struggle to pinpoint the reasons behind the growing bearish sentiment. The recent recovery in iron ore prices, which surpassed $111 per ton, coupled with a stable exchange rate of R$6 to the dollar, should theoretically bolster Vale’s prospects.

However, the stock continues to underperform compared to peers like BHP and Rio Tinto. Renato Chanes from Ágora Investimentos notes to local media that there are no new negative developments affecting Vale, making the current situation puzzling.

Several factors that previously weighed on Vale’s performance have been addressed. Concerns about leadership changes and legal liabilities from past environmental incidents have been resolved.

Vale Faces Market Uncertainty

Gustavo Pimenta now leads the company after taking over as CEO in October, ensuring continuity in management. Additionally, recent settlements regarding past environmental damages have aligned with market expectations.

Speculation suggests that the increased short interest may be linked to Cosan S.A. (CSAN3), which holds a 4.1% stake in Vale.

Cosan‘s management has indicated a desire to improve its capital structure, potentially leading to a sale of its Vale shares. This possibility could explain the heightened short-selling activity as investors anticipate a significant sell-off.

Market analysts emphasize that while the increase in borrowed shares is notable, it represents a small fraction of Vale‘s total outstanding shares.

Nonetheless, concerns about future iron ore prices loom large, particularly regarding China’s economic recovery and demand for commodities.

The volatility in iron ore prices—ranging from $135 at the beginning of 2024 to as low as $90—reflects these uncertainties. During recent investor presentations, Vale’s conservative projections for production and financial performance raised eyebrows.

Analysts had expected more optimistic figures. This cautious outlook may indicate that Vale anticipates continued challenges ahead.

LatAm Markets: Live Signals → — real-time movers, turnover leaders and FX across Latin America.