Brazil’s Factories Slipped in Nine of Fifteen Regions

Markets

Brazil industrial production slipped two tenths of a percent in May. The regional breakdown, published on Friday, shows a country pulling apart rather than slowing down together.

The Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics runs two versions of the same survey. One reports the national number, which came out a week ago; the other splits it by state, and landed today.

Nine of the fifteen places it measures produced less in May than in April. Six produced more.

That distinction matters because the national figure is an average of very different economies. It can sit close to zero while individual states move violently in opposite directions.

Where Brazil industrial production actually fell

Bahia carried the decline almost single-handedly, dropping close to nine percent in a month. Mato Grosso and the Northeast region as a whole each shed just over three percent.

Behind them came Minas Gerais, down about one and seven tenths of a percent, then Rio Grande do Sul and Pará, each down around one percent. Espírito Santo, Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo lost half a percent or less apiece.

On the other side, Ceará led the risers with a gain of just over three percent, a mirror image of the Northeast region’s fall. Pernambuco, Santa Catarina, Amazonas, Paraná and Goiás all gained ground.

Set the extremes side by side and the point becomes visible. On our own arithmetic, roughly twelve percentage points separate Bahia from Ceará, two states counted inside the very same Northeast aggregate that fell by three percent.

Why does Brazil industrial production look so uneven?

Because Brazilian states do not make the same things. A state dominated by petroleum refining moves with the oil cycle; one built on food processing moves with the harvest.

The national release names the culprits behind May’s decline. Coke, petroleum products and biofuels fell around six percent, and the extractive industries dropped some two and a half percent, the two heaviest negative influences of the month.

Those are precisely the industries concentrated in Bahia and in the Northeast, which is why one region can fall nine percent while the country as a whole barely moves. Sixteen of the twenty-five industrial branches actually grew.

The risers tell the same story from the other end. Pharmaceutical and pharmochemical products jumped by double digits, motor vehicles and trailers advanced, and chemical products gained.

Food products, textiles, printing, and computing and electronic equipment all pulled the other way. A month like this is less a slowdown than a reshuffle.

The number that matters more than the headline

Read past the monthly noise and one line stands out. Capital goods, the machines and equipment companies buy to expand or modernise a factory, have fallen more than six percent across the first five months of the year.

Every other broad category grew over the same period. Intermediate goods rose about two percent, semi-durable and non-durable consumer goods around one and a half, and durable consumer goods a little over half a percent.

Within capital goods the worst falls came in mixed-use equipment and agricultural machinery, each down by roughly a sixth. These are the purchases a company delays when borrowing is expensive.

Capital-goods output is read as a leading indicator of investment for exactly this reason. High interest rates and costlier credit are the standing explanation, and firms keep postponing expansion and re-equipment projects.

One month does not settle the argument. What it does is widen the gap between a category that signals future capacity and every category that reflects present demand.

Is Brazilian industry actually recovering?

Slowly, and from a low base. Output sits some four and a half percent above its pre-pandemic level but still roughly thirteen percent below the record set in May 2011.

The year-to-date gain has also cooled, from about one and seven tenths of a percent through April to roughly one and four tenths through May. Growth continues; the pace does not.

Background: Brazil’s Own VP Calls Its Tax System a ‘Madhouse’ That Repels Investors.

Background: our doing business in brazil a complete guide for foreign entrepreneurs guide.

What should a foreign investor take from this?

That a single national percentage tells you almost nothing about Brazil. Exposure to Bahia is exposure to refining; exposure to Santa Catarina is something else entirely.

There is a second reason to read the regional table rather than the national one. Brazil holds a general election in October, and industrial performance by state is the raw material of that argument.

A federal government will point to sixteen growing branches and a year-to-date expansion. An opposition will point to nine falling regions and to capital goods.

Both descriptions are accurate, which is the difficulty. The statistics agency has published a picture in which almost any political claim can find a supporting number.

Watch the capital-goods line rather than the headline. When firms resume buying machinery, the recovery has arrived; until then, industry is running on the demand it already has.