Brazil Fiscal Target Met Only Through Legal Carve-Outs
Brazil · ECONOMY
Key Facts
- —Definition The IFI is a non-partisan technical body attached to Brazil’s Federal Senate.
- —Primary result Federal revenue minus spending before interest payments on public debt.
- —2026 target Primary surplus of 0.25% of GDP, or R$34.3 billion, with a tolerance band.
- —Precatórios Court-ordered payments excluded from target verification, totaling R$55.7 billion.
- —Investor sentiment Negative outlook among fund managers rose from 40% to 54% in July 2026.
The underlying deficit is double the 2025 level, even as the target is formally met.
The Brazil fiscal target for 2026 will be met on paper, but only through legal carve-outs. Underneath them, the country’s finances are getting worse, not better.
The IFI, a technical watchdog attached to the Federal Senate, puts the effective primary deficit at about 0.4 percent of GDP.
The Two Faces of Brazil’s Fiscal Target
Brazil fiscal target for 2026 is set to be met, yet the numbers tell two very different stories. The IFI, or Instituição Fiscal Independente, is a non-partisan body attached to the Federal Senate that monitors public accounts.
According to its Fiscal Monitoring Report No. 115, the effective primary result. Revenue minus spending before interest—will be a deficit of about 0.4% of GDP.
In cash terms, that is a shortfall of R$52.0 billion for the year. Meanwhile, the result measured for Brazil fiscal target verification, after legal exclusions, should be a surplus of about 0.1% of GDP.
That is inside the tolerance band, so the target is formally met. The IFI published its Fiscal Monitoring Report No. 115 on Thursday 20 August 2026.
However, the report shows the effective deficit and the target-basis surplus coexist in the same year.
Brazil Fiscal Target: Primary Result Explained
The primary result is the balance of federal revenue minus spending before interest payments on the public debt. A primary deficit means non-interest spending exceeded revenue, which affects the Brazil fiscal target.
However, Brazil’s law distinguishes the ‘effective’ primary result from the result ‘for the purposes of verifying the target. ‘ The former counts everything and drives the debt path.
As a result, the two numbers for 2026 run in opposite directions: a deficit on the underlying measure. A surplus on the target-verification measure.
The effective primary result drives the debt path, while the target-basis measure is used for legal compliance. Meanwhile, the law allows certain items to be excluded from the latter calculation.
The Role of the IFI
The IFI is not part of the government. Instead, it is a technical body attached to the Federal Senate, the upper house of Congress.
Its projections are its own estimates, not official government figures. In its report, the IFI stresses that the effective deficit of about 0.4% of GDP is what matters for the debt trajectory.
The target-basis surplus is a separate, legally defined measure. The IFI’s criticism is that formal compliance with the primary result target ‘coexists with the realisation of effective primary deficits.
The IFI’s projections are its own estimates, not official government figures. Still, its analysis highlights the gap between formal compliance and the underlying fiscal reality.
The Target and Its Tolerance Band
The 2026 target is set by the LDO, or Lei de Diretrizes Orçamentárias, the Budget Guidelines Law passed by Congress. The centre of the target is a primary surplus of 0.25% of GDP, or R$34.3 billion.
The target carries a tolerance band of 0.25 percentage point of GDP either side. That gives an upper limit of about R$68.5 billion and a lower limit of R$0—zero deficit still counts as compliance.
Therefore, the projected target-basis surplus of about 0.1% of GDP falls within the band, so the target is met. The lower limit of the tolerance band is zero deficit, so any surplus counts as compliance.
Consequently, the projected surplus of 0.1% of GDP meets the target.
Legal Carve-Outs Explained
The main carve-out identified by name is precatórios, court-ordered payment orders issued when a final judgment goes against the state. These are legal obligations the government must pay, but they sit outside the primary target arithmetic.
The 2026 budget guidelines annex allows R$55.1 billion, equal to 0.40% of GDP, to be compensated out of the target calculation. In execution, the government reports R$55.7 billion of precatórios spending is not counted, citing a constitutional provision.
In short, formal compliance will be reached after legal deductions totalling R$62.8 billion on the government’s calculations and R$69.8 billion on the IFI’s. Plus use of the tolerance band.
Only precatórios are identified by name in the official documents as a deduction. However, the total deductions include other items not itemised in the sources consulted.
The Underlying Deficit Worsens
The IFI estimates a structural primary deficit of 1.4% of potential GDP in the four quarters to June 2026. That is double the 0.7% recorded in the same period of 2025.
This suggests the effective deficit is not a one-off but a trend. The IFI says the improvement in the target-basis result ‘mostly reflects downward revisions in projections of mandatory spending’ rather than a structural reversal.
In short, the legal carve-outs mask a deteriorating fiscal picture. The structural deficit doubled from 0.7% to 1.4% of potential GDP in a year.
As a result, the effective fiscal position is deteriorating despite the target being met.
Government Projections Improve
Moreover, the government’s own Primary Revenue and Expenditure Assessment Report, released in July. Raised the target-basis primary result from a projected surplus of R$4.1 billion to R$10.8 billion.
This came with no need for a spending freeze, known as contingenciamento. However, the IFI attributes this improvement to revisions in mandatory spending projections, not to a real improvement in the effective result.
Still, the government’s numbers show formal compliance is within reach without additional measures. The government’s July report raised the target-basis surplus to R$10.8 billion.
Nevertheless, the IFI says this reflects lower mandatory spending projections, not a structural improvement.
Investor Sentiment Turns Negative
Separately, investor sentiment has soured. Meanwhile.
A survey by XP found that the share of macro hedge-fund managers with a negative outlook for the Brazilian economy rose from 40% in June to 54% in August. The positive view fell from 24% to 8%.
This survey, taken before a Copom meeting, reflects the mood of 23 fund managers, not business confidence broadly. Even so, the pessimism aligns with the IFI’s concerns about the effective deficit.
The survey of 23 macro hedge-fund managers showed pessimism rising sharply. Meanwhile, the positive outlook fell from 24% to 8%, reflecting investor concerns.
What This Means for Brazil
In conclusion, Brazil’s fiscal target for 2026 will be met on paper, but the underlying reality is a growing deficit. The IFI’s projections highlight the gap between legal compliance and economic substance.
The use of carve-outs like precatórios is legal, but it raises questions about the credibility of the target. Investors seem to be taking note, as sentiment has turned negative.
Overall, the fiscal picture is more fragile than the headline target suggests. The fiscal target is met on paper, but the effective deficit persists.
Therefore, the credibility of the target may be questioned, as investors seem to notice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Brazil’s fiscal target for 2026?
The target is a primary surplus of 0.25% of GDP, or R$34.3 billion, with a tolerance band of 0.25 percentage point. The lower limit is zero, so a zero deficit still counts as compliance.
Why is the target met despite a deficit?
The target is met because of legal carve-outs, mainly precatórios, which are excluded from the target calculation. The effective primary deficit is about 0.4% of GDP, but the target-basis result is a small surplus.
What are precatórios?
Precatórios are court-ordered payment orders issued when a final judgment goes against the state. They are legal obligations but are excluded from the primary target arithmetic under a constitutional rule.
What is the IFI’s role?
The IFI is a non-partisan technical body attached to the Federal Senate. It monitors public accounts and publishes its own projections, which are not official government figures.
Connected Coverage
Sources: IFI/Senado Federal; Valor Econômico; Jornal do Comércio; InfoMoney; Brazil’s Ministry of Planning; Presidência da República.
This article was produced by The Rio Times’ automated newsroom system. How we use AI · Report an error
Read More from The Rio Times