Markets
Key Facts
—The headline. MRV&Co launched R$2.953bn ($573m) of housing in the second quarter, down 14.4% on a year earlier, while net sales rose 3.5% to R$2.75bn ($534m).
—The tell. Value fell faster than volume, with units launched down 12.8% against a 14.4% drop in value, and an average ticket of R$277,000 ($53,786).
—A promise tested. In its first-quarter filing the company predicted that a March sales bulge would lift second-quarter transfers, and transfers duly rose from 8,229 units to 9,803.
—The gap. Production still outran transfers, at 10,922 units built against 9,803 handed over, a shortfall of 1,119 units; the company says this mismatch strongly influences its cash generation.
—Cash. The group generated R$77.2m ($15m) of cash in the quarter, against a R$55.1m consumption a year earlier, with the development arm contributing R$121.1m ($23.5m).
—Backdrop. Brazil’s benchmark Selic rate stands at 14.25%, and MRV’s landbank shrank 6.8% over the year to R$40.9bn ($7.94bn).
Brazil homebuilder MRV sold slightly more housing in the second quarter than a year earlier, and launched considerably less of it, a divergence that says more about who can still get a mortgage than about the company itself.
MRV&Co, which describes itself as the largest residential builder in Latin America, published its operating preview for the second quarter on Thursday evening. The figures are preliminary and unaudited, and they are the first look investors get before the full accounts arrive.
Net sales at the Brazilian development arm reached two point seven five billion reais, a rise of three and a half percent on the same quarter of last year. Launches, measured by the total sales value of the projects put on the market, fell to two point nine five billion reais, down fourteen point four percent.
What the numbers say about Brazil homebuilder MRV
Look past the headline and a quieter fact emerges. The number of homes launched fell by twelve point eight percent, while their combined value fell by fourteen point four percent.
That comparison is ours, drawn from the two percentages the company reported. Value dropping faster than volume means the average home being launched is cheaper, and the mix is sliding down-market.
The average ticket bears it out at two hundred and seventy-seven thousand reais, or roughly fifty-four thousand dollars. That is a modest home, and it sits squarely inside the band served by Minha Casa Minha Vida, the federal programme that lends to lower-income buyers at rates well under the market.
The reason is not mysterious. Brazil’s benchmark interest rate sits at fourteen and a quarter percent, and mortgages priced off it have hollowed out the middle of the market, leaving the subsidised tier as the only reliable source of buyers.
The promise the company made in April
There is a way to judge this quarter that does not depend on anyone’s commentary, and it starts with a sentence the company wrote three months ago.
In its first-quarter operating preview, filed on 6 April, MRV told investors that sales had bunched heavily into March, and that this seasonal effect ought to push up the following quarter’s transfers. A transfer is the moment a finished home passes to its buyer and the bank releases the money, which is when the builder actually gets paid.
The prediction held. Transfers climbed from eight thousand two hundred and twenty-nine units in the first quarter to nine thousand eight hundred and three in the second, a rise of about nineteen percent by our arithmetic.
What the April note did not anticipate was that construction would run faster still. MRV built ten thousand nine hundred and twenty-two homes in the quarter and handed over nine thousand eight hundred and three of them.
Why a thousand unhanded-over homes matter more than they look
The difference is one thousand one hundred and nineteen homes, built but not yet handed to their buyers, and therefore not yet paid for. The company’s own preview identifies this mismatch between production and transfers as something that strongly influences its cash generation.
Each of those homes represents money spent on land, cement and labour that has not yet come back through the door. For a builder carrying heavy debt, the timing is not a rounding error but the whole game.
The gap is narrowing, though, which is the encouraging part. Set against the first quarter, when the shortfall was one thousand five hundred and eighteen homes, this quarter’s backlog equals a smaller slice of everything built, by our own calculation roughly ten percent against nearly sixteen.
Cash followed. The group turned a consumption of fifty-five million reais a year ago into a generation of seventy-seven million this time, with the Brazilian development business throwing off one hundred and twenty-one million.
The land that is quietly disappearing
One line in the preview points further ahead than the rest. MRV’s Brazilian landbank, the stock of plots it holds for future projects, was worth forty point nine billion reais at the end of the quarter, down six point eight percent over the year.
Land is the raw material of a launch. A builder whose landbank is shrinking is a builder that has already decided, quietly, to put less on the market in the quarters ahead.
The pressure to shrink comes partly from abroad. MRV spent the past few years building rental apartments in the United States through a subsidiary called Resia, ran into higher American interest rates than it planned for, and is now selling those assets to pay down debt.
That retreat has been expensive and public, and it explains the discipline on show at home. The Brazilian arm is being asked to generate cash rather than to grow.
What does the Brazil homebuilder MRV preview tell an outside investor?
That the Brazilian business is working and the interest rate is not. Sales, transfers and cash all improved, while the shrinking value of what MRV dares to launch shows a company retreating into the one segment the state still subsidises.
Why are launches falling while sales rise?
Because they measure different moments. Sales reflect demand for homes already on offer, mostly subsidised ones that still find buyers, whereas launches reflect what the company is willing to bet on next, and it is betting smaller and cheaper.
Is this good news or bad news for the share price?
The preview offers both, and the market will weigh them at the full results. Cash generation and the narrowing transfer gap argue one way, while a landbank down almost seven percent over the year and a down-market mix argue the other.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did MRV make or lose money on cash flow this quarter?
MRV generated R$77.2m ($15m) in cash this quarter, a clear improvement from burning through R$55.1m a year earlier, with its Brazilian development arm alone contributing R$121.1m ($23.5m).
Why are the homes MRV is launching getting cheaper?
Brazil's benchmark interest rate is 14.25%, which has priced most middle-income buyers out of the market, so MRV is focusing on lower-cost homes averaging R$277,000 ($53,786) that qualify for the government's subsidised Minha Casa Minha Vida lending programme.
What is MRV's landbank and why is it shrinking?
MRV's landbank is the stock of plots it holds for future projects, and it fell 6.8% over the year to R$40.9bn ($7.94bn), partly because the company is focused on generating cash rather than growing, after losses from its US rental apartment business forced it to sell assets and pay down debt.
Read More from The Rio Times