Key Points
— The US Second Circuit Court of Appeals annulled the conviction and 45-year sentence of former Honduras president Juan Orlando Hernández on April 8, ordering Judge Kevin Castel to dismiss the indictment entirely — a complete legal erasure
— Hernández had been convicted in 2024 of conspiring to import hundreds of tons of cocaine into the United States alongside Joaquín “El Chapo” Guzmán — Trump pardoned him in December 2025, and the appeals court’s ruling now eliminates the underlying charges
— Hernández called the ruling “total justice” and demanded Honduras lift its arrest warrant and return seized assets — his brother Tony Hernández remains imprisoned for life on separate narco charges
The Juan Orlando Hernández conviction annulled by a US appeals court is not just a pardon — it is a legal erasure of one of the most significant narco-trafficking prosecutions in Central American history, and it sends a signal about the limits of US drug enforcement when presidential politics intervene.
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals issued its ruling on April 8, 2026, ordering that the conviction, sentence, and indictment against Hernández be eliminated in their entirety, according to CNN en Español and El Heraldo (Honduras). Hernández’s wife, Ana García, held a press conference confirming the decision. “The news is official,” she said. “The resolution of the Court of Appeals is definitive.” Hernández himself posted on X: “The Court said clearly: eliminate the conviction, the sentence, and order the judge to erase it at the root. It is a complete erasure, it is total justice.”
The legal path to this outcome began in December 2025, when Trump issued a pardon. Attorney Renato Stabile then filed a motion on December 12 to vacate the conviction. Trump had justified the pardon by saying Hernández had been “treated with much harshness and injustice, according to many people I deeply respect.” The pardon came amid strong US pressure for Honduras to elect Nasry “Tito” Asfura, of Hernández’s National Party, in the November 2025 presidential election — which Asfura won.
The Case That Was
Hernández governed Honduras from 2014 to 2022. He was extradited to the United States in February 2022 under the Biden administration, immediately after leaving office. Federal prosecutors in the Southern District of New York charged him with three counts: conspiracy to import cocaine, conspiracy to possess firearms for drug trafficking, and weapons possession during narco-trafficking operations. The evidence presented at trial included testimony linking Hernández to the movement of hundreds of tons of cocaine through Honduras in partnership with Mexican cartels, including El Chapo Guzmán’s Sinaloa operation. He was convicted in 2024 and sentenced to 45 years.
Hernández now wants Honduras to lift its domestic arrest warrant and return seized family assets. His brother, former congressman Juan Antonio “Tony” Hernández, was convicted separately in 2021 and is serving a life sentence in the United States — no pardon has been issued for him. The complete annulment of JOH’s case raises questions about the durability of US narco-trafficking prosecutions when they intersect with presidential politics, and about the signal it sends to current and future Central American leaders whose cooperation Washington may need on migration, security, or other priorities.